When Grammar Is Not Enough: Why Legal Translation Requires Logical and Contextual Reasoning
A legal translation may be grammatically correct yet logically inaccurate. This article examines how the mistranslation of “Safeguards to the EU SCC” illustrates the importance of contextual reasoning, semantic relationships, and legal logic in professional translation.
Hipyan Nopri
9/2/20268 min read


Legal translation is not merely a matter of replacing words in one language with their apparent equivalents in another. A translation may be grammatically correct and still be legally or logically misleading. This is particularly true when prepositions, modifiers, and noun relationships are rendered mechanically, without considering what the provision is actually intended to regulate.
For organizations that sign, file, or rely on translated agreements, privacy notices, and compliance documents, this distinction is far from academic. The translated version is often the one read by local counterparties, employees, and regulators. If it describes the wrong legal relationship, it may say something the original never said.
A Small Phrase with a Large Consequence
I encountered a useful example of this problem while reviewing a translated data-protection document. The source text contained the following section heading:
Safeguards to the EU SCC
It had been rendered into Indonesian as:
Perlindungan terhadap SCC UE
The Indonesian phrase can be understood as "protection directed at, or against, the EU SCC." At first glance, the rendering appears linguistically plausible: safeguards has been translated as perlindungan, and EU SCC has been retained as SCC UE. The difficulty becomes apparent only when the phrase is examined logically rather than lexically.
The EU Standard Contractual Clauses are not the object that requires protection. They are a contractual mechanism that establishes obligations and protections for the transfer of personal data. Under Article 46 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), a controller or processor may transfer personal data to a third country only if appropriate safeguards are in place, and standard data protection clauses adopted by the European Commission are one of the recognized means of providing them (Regulation (EU) 2016/679, art. 46(2)(c)). The current clauses were adopted by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914. In other words, the SCC are themselves a source of safeguards, not their target.
The context confirmed this reading. The text beneath the heading described the safeguards required under the clauses. Reading the heading as perlindungan terhadap SCC UE therefore creates an illogical relationship, suggesting that the SCC are something to be protected.
The heading was accordingly revised to:
Perlindungan sesuai dengan SCC (Standard Contractual Clauses, Klausul Kontrak Standar) UE
The difference may appear small, but it is significant. The revised wording makes clear that the safeguards are provided in accordance with the EU SCC. The SCC function as the governing framework under which the safeguards are established; they are not the object of those safeguards.
What the Dictionary Says About "To"
It is worth asking why the phrase invites misreading in the first place. The English preposition to has an unusually wide range of meanings. Merriam-Webster lists, among others, three senses that are directly relevant here (Merriam-Webster, n.d.):
Direction (sense 1): to indicates actual or figurative movement or direction toward a place, person, or thing.
Connection (sense 4): to indicates addition, attachment, connection, or belonging, as in the key to the door.
Conformity (sense 6b): to indicates agreement or conformity, as in add salt to taste, a gown made to her specifications, or to my knowledge.
The rendering terhadap reflects the directional sense: the safeguards are understood as being directed toward the SCC. The conformity sense points elsewhere. Read in that sense, safeguards to the EU SCC means safeguards that conform to the EU SCC, in the same way that a garment made to specifications is one made in accordance with them. This is precisely the relationship expressed by sesuai dengan.
One might be tempted to explain the phrase by treating to as a shortened form of pursuant to or according to. The dictionary shows that this is unnecessary: the meaning of conformity already belongs to the established range of senses of to itself. The translator's task is not to reconstruct a missing word, but to determine which of the available senses the context activates.
The Problem Is Not Vocabulary
What makes this type of error instructive is that it cannot be resolved simply by looking up individual words. The words safeguards, EU, and SCC are not especially difficult. Even the dictionary entry for to does not by itself supply the answer; it offers several possible senses, and context must decide among them. The real issue is the relationship between the elements of the phrase.
In legal translation, understanding such relationships is essential. A translator must continually ask:
What is being protected?
Who benefits from the protection?
What instrument creates or regulates that protection?
Is a particular noun the object of an obligation, the source of an obligation, or the legal framework governing it?
Does the translated preposition preserve the same logical relationship as the source?
These questions concern legal and linguistic reasoning rather than vocabulary alone.
The Indonesian preposition terhadap establishes a relationship in which SCC UE appears to be the object toward which the protection is directed. In this context, that interpretation does not make conceptual sense. The intended relationship is one of conformity or legal basis: the safeguards are those provided or required under the EU SCC. This is why sesuai dengan produces a more coherent formulation.
Prepositions Can Change Legal Meaning
Prepositions are often underestimated because they are short and seemingly simple. In legal texts, however, they can determine the logical structure of an entire phrase. Consider the following:
protection against X
protection for X
protection under X
protection pursuant to X
protection in accordance with X
These expressions do not describe the same relationship. A translation that focuses only on lexical equivalence may overlook the distinction. Yet legal documents depend heavily on relationships: between rights and beneficiaries, obligations and obligors, rules and regulated parties, agreements and governing provisions, and safeguards and the instruments that establish them.
The wrong preposition can therefore create the wrong legal relationship even when every major noun has been translated correctly.
Translation Requires Referential Logic
Another useful way of analyzing the problem is to identify the semantic roles of the elements involved. When a legal text refers to safeguards in connection with contractual clauses, the translator should determine:
What provides or defines the safeguards? The contractual framework.
Who or what is protected by them? The data subjects, the personal data, and the interests addressed by the clauses.
Are the contractual clauses themselves the protected object? No.
Once these roles are identified, the weakness of perlindungan terhadap SCC UE becomes evident.
This analysis is especially important because legal texts frequently compress complex relationships into short noun phrases. English allows nouns and prepositional structures to be combined compactly, particularly in headings. Indonesian often requires the translator to make the underlying relationship explicit. A literal translation may preserve the surface structure while losing the intended logic.
Legal Translation Is an Exercise in Interpretation
This example illustrates a broader principle: every competent legal translation involves a degree of interpretation.
This does not mean that translators are free to rewrite legal documents according to personal preference. On the contrary, the translator's responsibility is to interpret the grammatical and contextual relationships accurately enough to reproduce them in the target language without adding or removing legal meaning. That process involves several levels of analysis at once:
Lexical analysis identifies the possible meanings of individual words.
Syntactic analysis determines how those words are grammatically related.
Semantic analysis determines what those relationships mean.
Contextual analysis determines which interpretation makes sense within the document.
Legal reasoning determines whether the resulting interpretation is coherent within the relevant legal framework.
A translation can succeed at the first level and fail at the remaining four. That is why literal accuracy should never be confused with substantive accuracy.
A Grammatically Acceptable Translation Can Still Be Wrong
Some of the most difficult errors to detect are those that sound perfectly natural. Obvious grammatical mistakes attract attention immediately. Logical errors are more dangerous because the sentence may read smoothly while communicating the wrong relationship.
Perlindungan terhadap SCC UE is a good example. Nothing in the phrase is ungrammatical, and Indonesian readers can follow its structure. The problem is that its structure leads them toward an implausible interpretation. This is rarely a matter of carelessness; it is a natural consequence of treating prepositions as fixed equivalents.
This is where careful review becomes particularly valuable. A reviewer should not ask only, "Does this sound natural in Indonesian?" but also, "Does this actually mean what the source intends?" In legal translation, one further question is essential: "Does the relationship expressed in the translation make legal and logical sense?" If the answer is no, stylistic fluency cannot rescue the translation.
Why Context Must Override Mechanical Equivalence
Mechanical translation habits often rest on the assumption that every source-language preposition has a stable target-language equivalent. It does not.
The correct Indonesian rendering of an English preposition depends on the semantic relationship it expresses in a particular context. The same English preposition may require terhadap, kepada, untuk, berdasarkan, sesuai dengan, berdasarkan ketentuan, or another formulation, depending on its function. As the dictionary entry for to shows, a single preposition may carry directional, relational, and conformity meanings, each calling for a different Indonesian rendering.
The same principle applies to many apparently simple structures in legal texts:
Rights under the agreement should not be translated as though the rights were physically "below" an agreement.
Obligations pursuant to the law refers to obligations arising under or governed by law.
Protection under the regulation normally refers to protection afforded by the regulation, not protection directed toward the regulation itself.
The translator's task is to identify the underlying legal relationship and express it naturally in the target language. Translators must translate relationships, not prepositions in isolation.
A Practical Logic Check
Subject-matter knowledge alone is not sufficient. A translator may be familiar with legal terminology and still produce unreliable translations if the resulting sentences are not tested for logical coherence. A useful discipline is to perform a logic check after completing a draft:
Who is doing what?
To whom?
Under what authority?
For whose benefit?
What is the object of the action?
What is the governing instrument?
What is the legal consequence?
If the answers implied by the target text differ from those implied by the source, the translation needs to be reconsidered. This method is particularly useful for agreements, privacy policies, data-protection documents, compliance materials, regulations, and contractual clauses, where a small change in relational wording may significantly affect meaning.
What This Means for Those Who Rely on the Translation
For a legal team, a compliance officer, or a business preparing documents for Indonesian counterparties or authorities, the practical lesson is straightforward. A translation should be judged not only by whether it reads well, but by whether it preserves who owes what, to whom, and on what legal basis. In data-protection documents especially, a heading or clause that misstates the role of an instrument such as the SCC can blur the very framework the document is meant to establish.
In my own practice, this is why every legal translation is reviewed not only for terminology and fluency, but also for the logical relationships it creates. The logic check described above is part of that review, because it is often where the most consequential issues come to light.
Conclusion
The rendering of Safeguards to the EU SCC as Perlindungan terhadap SCC UE demonstrates a fundamental lesson in legal translation: linguistic competence must be accompanied by logical and contextual reasoning.
The issue was not a lack of vocabulary. The English preposition to can indicate direction, connection, or conformity, and the translation adopted the directional sense where the context and the legal function of the SCC called for conformity. The SCC are not the object of the protection; they constitute the framework in accordance with which the safeguards are established. Perlindungan sesuai dengan SCC (Standard Contractual Clauses, Klausul Kontrak Standar) UE conveys that relationship coherently in Indonesian.
A translator who asks only, "What does this word mean?" may produce a grammatically acceptable sentence. A translator who also asks, "What does this sentence logically mean in this legal context?" is far more likely to produce a translation on which its readers can safely rely.
References
Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 of 4 June 2021 on standard contractual clauses for the transfer of personal data to third countries pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council. Official Journal of the European Union, L 199, 7 June 2021, pp. 31–61.
Merriam-Webster. (n.d.). To. In Merriam-Webster.com dictionary. Retrieved September 2, 2026, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/to
Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation). Official Journal of the European Union, L 119, 4 May 2016, pp. 1–88.
